With regard to findings of parental alienation, it is important to note that allegations of parental alienation often arise in legal proceedings, whether or not violence is involved. It is very important to mention this. It is, however, quite difficult for judges, and even for lawyers, to determine who is telling the truth in such cases.
The Quebec Court of Appeal's judgment in Droit de la famille—24915 provides a definition of parental alienation. The context was somewhat different, as this judgment was handed down in the context of a civil liability claim where the aim was to establish the concept of fault. At the very least, it clarified certain points, even though case law did not necessarily always agree on the same definition of parental alienation or on the standard required to conclude that parental alienation was present. It should be noted that this concept is also the subject of some controversy within the field of psychology.
In any case, what we observe is that, in every definition we come across, it really requires behaviour that is inappropriate given the family dynamics, that is systematic, and whose aim is to exclude the other parent.
That said, these are still just labels. It is good to be aware of the issue, and I believe it is a priority to raise awareness among judges and solicitors through fairly in-depth training to help them distinguish fact from fiction. The fact remains that, in every case—whether or not parental alienation is present, whether or not there is domestic violence—we must ask ourselves what is in the child's best interests. In every instance, it is worthwhile, and indeed necessary, to examine all the circumstances.