Evidence of meeting #51 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site.) The winning word was framework.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Acting Vice-President, Consumer, Analytics and Strategy, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Apse  Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health
Clare  Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health
Hutton  Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Legault  Legislative Clerk
Awad  Director General, Digital and Creative Marketplace Frameworks, Department of Canadian Heritage

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

Do I have some time to answer that?

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Not really, but go ahead.

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

I shouldn't have asked.

Voices

Oh, oh!

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

Perhaps I will bookend it where we started, which was the evidence of a problem. In the tobacco space, it was a nationally pressing concern that caused the government at the time to take action against promotion and advertising with respect to tobacco.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Lawton, you have the floor for five minutes.

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

Thank you, witnesses, for being here.

This is just to understand the context of Health Canada's contributions here. Again, I'm not aware of how you two ended up being able to spend time with us, but do you have someone who is tasked with looking at the effects of gambling through a public health lens? Does that program exist in your department?

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

Perhaps I will just say that we're here from a tobacco and cannabis perspective. The Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction takes a look at some of those aspects. Then there's a lot of work being done with respect to men and boys and looking at that issue as well. My colleague, John, talked about the impact of what we call polysubstance use. It's from that perspective that we would consider that.

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Would I be correct in reading from what you've said there that sports betting, or gambling in general, is not a public health priority for Health Canada? You don't have a parallel directorate that is dealing with this issue the way you do for tobacco and cannabis.

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

No, I wouldn't draw that conclusion. We're representatives of a specific program, you're right, that looks at the public health harms associated with substance use. Krista looks after tobacco, I look after cannabis and we have a colleague who looks after the other drugs, the other bad drugs. A separate part of Health Canada looks specifically at mental health. There is generally that examination of mental health, and the public health agency as well—

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

It's under the mental health banner.

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

That's right.

4:30 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

Okay. That's helpful. Thank you very much.

Looking back at the historical development of tobacco particularly, because we have a little bit more of a longitudinal analysis there, when decisions were made to ban celebrity endorsements, for example, did you see compliance with that? The context of my question is that in Ontario, as an example, it is banned, but you still see them all the time. There are still creative ways around it. A sports betting ad will have a pro athlete on there because they've been given some title and they're now actually there as a representative of a company and not as a celebrity.

Did you see that issue in the tobacco world?

4:30 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

Maybe I'll answer a little bit differently.

There's no question that creativity goes on out there, whether it's the cannabis space, the tobacco space or other spaces like this. Specifically in our tobacco reporting regulations, we do require companies to submit information about marketing and research. We're constantly trying to stay a little bit ahead of what's going on in that space so that we can anticipate the issues, start to understand and look at the evidence, and take action where we need to take action.

4:35 p.m.

Conservative

Andrew Lawton Conservative Elgin—St. Thomas—London South, ON

The problem I have with Bill S-211, not specific to the bill but with national frameworks in general, is that the best it can do is to get provinces to come to the table and hope that they want to take action on their own, whereas right now we are seeing, even when there are stringent restrictions in place, non-compliance with those.

I'm trying to temper expectations here. Did you have that issue when you look back historically? I know you weren't in that role at the time, but knowing what you know now, did you have that issue with federal control or federal restrictions on tobacco advertising, or did you generally see compliance?

4:35 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

It might be instructive for the committee to understand that when the government legalized cannabis for non-medical purposes back in 2017-18, this was a question to the government: Should the bill include strict restrictions on advertising and promotion, or do we leave it to codes of practice the way we do for alcohol? Do you follow an alcohol model or do you follow a tobacco model?

The advice that the government was given by an expert panel, who gave advice on the creation of the framework, was to follow the tobacco model—really, really strict, enforceable and strong penalties. That's what the Cannabis Act enacted. Were there compliance issues with that? Absolutely. Especially in the early days with cannabis, there were a lot of celebrity endorsements at the time. I won't name them, because I don't want to give them their promotional bump, but that was an issue.

Did the government have the tools in the tool box to go after that and enforce compliance and return those companies to compliance? Absolutely they did. Do there continue to be compliance issues today? Absolutely. I have colleagues for whom it's a full-time job. I would say that it's instructive that in the cannabis space, based on the tobacco model, we were successfully able to address that issue of celebrity endorsement.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Next I will pass the floor over to Mr. Al Soud for five minutes.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you all for taking the time to be with us today. It is truly appreciated.

I find that there is, at times, a bit of a disparity between us as parliamentarians and the realities in digital environments.

Mr. Carter, you co-authored the CRTC's “Harnessing Change” report. In it, you highlight many of the challenges associated with regulating communication services in an increasingly digital and platform-driven environment. Could you speak to some of those challenges, particularly those that might be relevant to today's conversation? How has that growing complexity maybe exposed gaps in the way we as policy-makers, regulators and industry platforms understand and measure Canadians' exposure to advertising?

4:35 p.m.

Acting Vice-President, Consumer, Analytics and Strategy, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Sheehan Carter

Wow. That's a tough question.

Yes, absolutely. Our broadcasting environment has changed a great deal just in the last 15 years, I would say. In fact, the changes have been transformative. Our traditional system operates in an environment in which their revenues are declining rapidly. They're looking for alternative means of gaining revenues wherever they can. We have an online environment that is also evolving very rapidly. Despite their increasing revenues overall, they are searching for other opportunities as well. They're delving into the advertising space, which has traditionally been a very important area for traditional broadcasters. Their, perhaps, incursion and their attempts to gain revenue through that space has continued and, I would say, amplified the effect of the presence of digital services within the environment.

As a regulator, we have just relatively recently begun our efforts to move into the digital space, and there are a lot of challenges. The first challenge was data. How do we get some data that we can use to determine what regulatory frameworks are going to be appropriate and how are they going to work moving forward? Even a few years later, we still struggle with data and with making sure we have the data we need.

Beyond that, we've been progressively implementing what was Bill C-11 and moving into various areas of digital regulation. It has been a slow and, at times, very challenging effort on our part. We are now, I would say, a couple of years into our regulatory road map. On our website, you can take a look at what our plans are in detail. It is a staged development and it does take some time.

You can see on our road map that we will be looking at how our codes could apply to online services moving forward, but that's an effort that takes second place to some of our work with respect to contribution and other areas promoting Canadian content.

Fares Al Soud Liberal Mississauga Centre, ON

Fantastic.

We've discussed at length here in committee this notion of doom scrolling. I think we're all prone to doing so every now and then. I spent half an hour on a certain platform the other day, and I think I stumbled onto nine different gambling advertisements. I think that speaks to points my colleagues were making earlier about the proliferation of advertising at large within this space, in that what was once a very wholesome, very good environment—that is, sports—where you could expect that you would engage with that as a subject, period, has now changed significantly.

There's also, I think, an expectation sometimes that the CRTC is ever so involved in absolutely everything.

Could you help the committee understand what the authority of the CRTC is as it pertains to advertising practices? How might that defer to ad standards, for instance?

4:40 p.m.

Acting Vice-President, Consumer, Analytics and Strategy, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Sheehan Carter

Our role with respect to content in general is quite limited. Our mandate leans towards the promotion and ensuring the discoverability and availability of Canadian content.

With respect to the content itself, we have a very limited role. That is why we generally operate in an environment of co-regulation, as my colleague Mr. Hutton has explained.

With respect to advertising specifically, the commission is directly involved in only a very small amount of advertising. We were involved in the development of a code with respect to alcohol. We were involved in the development of a code with respect to children's advertising. These were all decades ago, though.

Generally, our formula or our system—and it's been a very successful one, I think, in terms of the co-regulatory model that Mr. Hutton described—is to allow the industry to develop a code, to impose that code on broadcasters through regulation, through our public consultations on which all our decisions are based, and then allow an independent third party to handle complaints with respect to those codes.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

That concludes our time for this panel.

Thank you to all of you for being here to answer our questions today.

We will suspend for a couple of minutes. We will come back with officials from the Department of Canadian Heritage, and we will commence our clause-by-clause consideration of this bill.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

As I mentioned before the break, we are going into clause-by-clause consideration of Bill S-211.

We have with us, from the Department of Canadian Heritage, Charlene Budnisky, senior director, communication, legislative and regulatory policy; and Amy Awad, director general, digital and creative marketplace frameworks.

I understand that you're here to answer questions about the bill, should members have any, while we're going through the bill clause by clause.

I would like to provide members of the committee with a few comments on how committees proceed with clause-by-clause consideration of a bill. As the name indicates, this is an examination of all the clauses in the order in which they appear in the bill. I will call each clause successively, and each clause is subject to debate and a vote. If there are amendments to the clause in question, I will recognize the member proposing it, who may explain it. The amendment will then be open for debate. When no further members wish to intervene, the amendment will be voted on.

Amendments will be considered in the order in which they appear in the package each member received from the clerk. During debate on an amendment, members are permitted to move subamendments. Only one subamendment may be considered at a time, and that subamendment cannot be amended.

Once every clause has been voted on, the committee will vote on the title and the bill itself.

I thank members for their attention and wish everyone a productive clause-by-clause consideration of Bill S-211.

Pursuant to Standing Order 75(1), consideration of clause 1—the short title—and the preamble are postponed.

(On clause 2)

Since there are amendments to clause 2, the interpretation clause, I suggest that we postpone the study of clause 2 until the end. This will allow us to first consider and then make a decision on amendments that could have an impact on the definitions. In House of Commons Procedure and Practice, fourth edition, we can read:

The interpretation clause of a bill is not the place to propose a substantive amendment to a bill unless other amendments have been adopted that would warrant amendments to the interpretation clause.

May I have consensus from members that we consider clause 2 after clause 6?

Some hon. members

Agreed.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

(Clause 2 allowed to stand)

We will move on to new clause 2.1 and amendment G-2. Somebody needs to move that.

Go ahead, Mr. Myles.