Evidence of meeting #51 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site.) The winning word was framework.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Acting Vice-President, Consumer, Analytics and Strategy, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Apse  Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health
Clare  Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health
Hutton  Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Legault  Legislative Clerk
Awad  Director General, Digital and Creative Marketplace Frameworks, Department of Canadian Heritage

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you. That was nice and tidy. We'll pass it over to the Department of Health.

Go ahead.

Krista Apse Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Thank you.

Chair and committee members, my name is Krista Apse. I am the director general of the tobacco control directorate at Health Canada.

I am joined today by my colleague, John Clare, director general of the Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate.

Tobacco and cannabis promotion and sports betting advertising operate in different contexts. I'll be speaking today to the lessons learned from Health Canada's experience in regulating tobacco and cannabis products. I'm hopeful that an overview of the regulation of tobacco promotion will help to provide the committee with information about how promotion can normalize behaviour and influence uptake, particularly among young people.

Indeed, protecting young persons and others from inducements to use harmful substances like tobacco and cannabis is a central objective of both the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act and the Cannabis Act.

Long-standing evidence shows that product promotions from tobacco companies are intended to not only communicate information about the product but also create the perception that tobacco use is desirable, healthy and more common in society than it really is. These effects are particularly concerning for adolescents and young adults for whom promotion influences perceptions of risk and acceptability, increases appeal and may encourage experimentation. In 2022, 71% of people who smoke reported smoking their first cigarette before the age of 18.

As the evidence base regarding the impacts of tobacco promotion came into focus, these concerns helped shape the government's response. Beginning with national restrictions on tobacco advertising in 1989, the federal framework expanded over time. Today, the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act addresses a broad range of promotional practices, including sponsorships, endorsements, advertising, incentives, packaging and product appearance.

Tobacco companies historically sought to associate their brands with entertainment and other activities that conveyed excitement and success, for example, a tobacco advertisement on a race car, in a sports stadium or at a concert. Similarly, testimonials from celebrities promoted tobacco by transferring the appeal of a well-known person to a product. Federal prohibitions were introduced to prevent these associations and their ability to increase the appeal and normalization of tobacco use.

Lessons learned from tobacco helped inform the establishment of comparable controls under the Cannabis Act. In line with tobacco, the act places comprehensive prohibitions on cannabis promotion, including prohibiting promotion that appeals to young persons, uses testimonials or endorsements or associates cannabis with a particular lifestyle. These restrictions are intended to protect young persons and others from inducements to use cannabis.

Turning back to tobacco, as conventional forms of tobacco sponsorships and lifestyle promotions were prohibited, the packaging itself became a more important marketing tool for tobacco companies. Colour, imagery, logos, brand descriptions and the appearance of the product itself were used to communicate an identity and create impressions about the product.

The supporting regulations use a combination of health warnings, health information messages and toxicity information to inform users of the health hazards and health effects associated with the use of tobacco. Plain and standardized packaging requirements strip away promotional features and reduce appeal by requiring packages to be of the same drab brown colour, bearing only permitted text displayed in a standard location, font style, colour and size, among other requirements.

Similarly, the Cannabis Act and its regulations impose strict requirements on the packaging and labelling of cannabis products, including plain packaging requirements, a standardized cannabis warning symbol and health warning messages.

While I understand that packaging and labelling may not be directly attributed to the sports betting context, it does illustrate a key take-away from the tobacco file: Success requires vigilance to adapt controls as promotions evolve.

In terms of results, Canada's smoking rates are among the lowest in the world. In 2024, less than 1% of youth smoked daily, which is one of the most significant public health achievements of the past 25 years.

However, no single measure or control accounts for Canada's progress.

These measures are complemented by a suite of measures including pan-Canadian public education campaigns. The government is also investing in clinical and community programs.

In closing, I would also like to reinforce that eradicating the harms of tobacco use is very much a partnership and a shared responsibility.

I want to acknowledge provincial, territorial, first nations, Inuit and Métis partners, whose vital work is essential to addressing the harms of tobacco use.

Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you very much to you both.

We'll start our questioning with Ned Kuruc for six minutes.

You have the floor.

3:55 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Thank you very much.

Thank you to all the witnesses for coming today.

This framework is very important, and I'd first like to thank you to Health Canada for the work you've done on tobacco and cannabis. I'm in the legal cannabis business, but I still adhere to and agree with all the restrictions on advertising, so thank you very much for that.

Gambling is one of those things that has hit my age group in my community pretty hard, especially with sports betting. For someone like me who has seen friends with gambling addictions and so on and so forth since online sports betting became legalized—and we see what it is today—it's been quite concerning.

I am the shadow minister for sport. I was an athlete and this and that. We see now where sports and betting have become one, where people are watching sports and the advertising that goes with it, so it's normalizing gambling through sports. I find this very concerning for our youth.

There are some statistics that I want to share. Online sports betting among Ontario students in grades 7 to 12 has been 10 times more prevalent since 2019. I find that very alarming. People with gambling problems are four times more likely to report moderate to severe anxiety symptoms, as well as four times more likely to report suicidal thoughts. New research finds that 77% of young men are exposed to betting advertisements on a weekly basis, with 60% reporting that these ads influence their betting behaviour. That one is an interesting statistic. It's a statistic that reports on what they're doing while they're betting. That's very alarming to me.

I would like to ask either person from Health Canada this question: Because of your experience restricting advertising for legal products that carry addiction risks, including tobacco and cannabis, as was mentioned, what lessons from those regulations could we consider when amending this bill?

John Clare Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

I appreciate the question, Madam Chair. I'll do my best to be helpful.

I think that lessons can be applied from the tobacco legislation. The framework to control promotion in cannabis was largely based on the framework that was established to address tobacco. The application of lessons to different harms or whatnot is definitely a smart way of governing.

I think the key things, the key lessons.... You spoke to different statistics. I think the main thing is that you need to establish what is the purpose that your control.... Essentially, when you regulate promotion and advertising, you're engaging freedom of expression.

For whatever control framework you put in place, you need to make sure that you're addressing a pressing and substantial need. What is the issue that you're trying to address? You need to have the evidence to demonstrate that there is a real issue here. In this case, the issue you're exploring is the detrimental impact of sports betting on members of Canadian society.

4 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

Yes, specifically youth.

4 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

Yes.

The second thing you need to do is demonstrate that there's a rational connection between your control and that purpose. You need to have evidence that shows that promotion in particular is connected to rates of gambling, of problematic gambling, among the subpopulation or population you're attempting to address.

Then, you also need to make sure that your control, your limit, is minimally impairing: that your regulatory control is targeted and tailored to the extent necessary to address that harm. You can't have broad things. As officials, when we're thinking about constructing a regulatory control that would limit freedom of expression, that's what you're trying to do. Krista, my colleague, spoke to that: having that evidence to support that.

4 p.m.

Conservative

Ned Kuruc Conservative Hamilton East—Stoney Creek, ON

My main concern is that there are a lot of parents out there who like watching sports with their children or vice versa. It becomes a family event. I think there are a lot of Canadians who don't want sports to be infected with gambling advertising. They don't want to watch Sunday football with their children and have that experience become a gambling experience—or one day become a gambling experience. That's what my concern is.

If your colleague wants to speak to a few things on my concerns there—or anyone else as well—I would love to listen.

4 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

Chair, I'll come at it from a bit of a different perspective as well. I would come at it in terms of the purpose of the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act itself. I have it here in front of me. I'll read a couple of passages that drive home that point:

to protect young persons and others from inducements to use tobacco products and the consequent dependence on them;

to prevent the public from being deceived or misled with respect to the health hazards of using tobacco products;

I've chosen a couple. I would invite the committee to take a look at the purpose of the act from the tobacco perspective.

Similarly, on vaping, it says:

to protect young persons and non-users of tobacco products from inducements to use vaping products;

It also says:

to protect the health of young persons and non-users of tobacco products from exposure to and dependence on nicotine that could result from the use of vaping products;

There are a couple of others there as well.

I think it does go back to the purpose of what you're intending to do and the measures that would need to be put in place to enact that purpose.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Ms. Auguste, you have the floor for six minutes.

Tatiana Auguste Liberal Terrebonne, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

I'd like to thank the witnesses for appearing today as part of this important study.

I would like to begin with the representatives of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission, or CRTC.

If possible, could you explain to the committee what the CRTC is legally mandated to regulate with respect to advertising under the Broadcasting Act? In particular, what aspects of advertising standards does the CRTC deliberately leave to others to oversee? What are the respective roles, and where is the line drawn between them?

Scott Hutton Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

I can start.

The Broadcasting Act only allows us to regulate broadcasters. That's the first key element of the legislation. The act also provides that we may regulate advertising, both with respect to its content or social content, through mechanisms such as the codes we have in place, and with respect to the amount of time devoted to advertising. Broadly speaking, that is the scope of the authority granted to us under the act.

Over the years, we have developed various approaches to achieve those objectives. We are strong proponents of the co-regulatory model. We have been working in that manner successfully for decades. In fact, this model has been adopted in a number of other jurisdictions around the world.

More specifically, we also work with our colleagues at Health Canada, particularly with regard to alcohol and the two products we're discussing here.

In the context of the matter before us, we've also begun working with another branch of Health Canada to better understand the effects of advertising on young people and more broadly on Canadians, and to develop advertising standards that support the objectives of the legislation we're discussing today.

That's essentially how we operate. When there's a prohibition or some other specific consideration, we rely heavily on our colleagues who are experts in the health of Canadians to help us develop codes which, depending on the circumstances, may either be incorporated into broadcasters' conditions of licence or implemented through a more co-regulatory approach.

Tatiana Auguste Liberal Terrebonne, QC

Thank you very much.

At present, certain products may not be advertised on television or radio. Could you tell us what legislation or regulations are in place to ensure that such products are in fact prohibited from being advertised? In practical terms, how do you prevent those advertisements from being broadcast?

4:05 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

I can begin from the broadcasting perspective, and then I think the question should be directed to our colleagues from Health Canada.

From our standpoint, where there's a complete prohibition, it's usually established through government policy and set out in legislation. In the case of the codes we have implemented, there are often clear objectives and policy signals, as our colleagues mentioned earlier in response to Mr. Kuruc. Objectives are established, research is conducted and frameworks are developed in collaboration with experts. Those codes are then imposed on broadcasters through conditions of licence.

Tatiana Auguste Liberal Terrebonne, QC

Thank you very much.

4:05 p.m.

Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health

Krista Apse

I'd like to add something.

I'll use vaping products as an example.

The vaping products promotion regulations prohibit the promotion of vaping products and vaping product-related brand elements through advertising that is done in a manner that can “be seen or heard by young persons”, including online. The regulations state that regulated parties “advertising vaping products online must effectively restrict youth access by verifying the age and identity of all visitors to effectively restrict youth access to the advertising.”

Health Canada inspectors monitor the websites and social media accounts of manufacturers and retailers to verify compliance with the legislative and regulatory requirements. While reviewing that publicly available website and domain registration information, inspectors may examine websites, social media accounts or other information linked to the regulatory party for details. In some cases, they may contact domain registrars, web hosting companies and other Internet service providers to request registrant contact information for the purpose of issuing compliance communication to the website owner.

Tatiana Auguste Liberal Terrebonne, QC

Thank you very much.

I have a question for the CRTC. Bill S‑211 requires the CRTC to submit its review report to the minister within one year of royal assent. Given its current capacity and resources, is the CRTC in a position to meet that deadline?

4:10 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

I believe the answer is yes.

We've already begun our preparatory work, and we'll be ready when royal assent is granted. With our current resources, and by adjusting our priorities accordingly, we will be in a position to table the required report.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Champoux, you have six minutes.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Thank you very much, Madam Chair.

I'd like to thank the witnesses for being here today.

I am going to direct a question to the CRTC. It's a question that I could also put to the witnesses from Health Canada, but I'll begin with you, Mr. Carter and Mr. Hutton.

When it comes to the regulation of sports betting advertising, and indeed the regulation of sports betting itself, the provinces have adopted different models. Quebec has its own model, and Ontario has another, for example.

Are you familiar with the various models that exist across the provinces for the management and regulation of online gambling, as well as for advertising related to online gambling?

I would appreciate a response from either one of you.

4:10 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

Yes, we're familiar with them. We've begun reviewing and comparing the various models and taking stock of the current landscape. The province that is furthest along at the moment, particularly with respect to broadcasting and advertising, is Ontario, which has worked closely with the Canadian Code of Advertising Standards.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Without getting into evaluations or personal opinions, could you explain the different models to us? What are the differences that lead some to conclude that federal intervention is required in this area?

4:10 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

As you mentioned, each province has adopted a different approach. Some are more advanced than others. Some have much more comprehensive frameworks governing sports betting, while others have not yet fully authorized sports betting or established a robust regulatory framework. There is considerable variation across the country.

There are also different regulatory structures. In some cases, there's a separate regulator. In Quebec, for example, the Régie des alcools, des courses et des jeux is responsible for the regulatory framework, while Loto‑Québec oversees sports betting. That's one model. Other jurisdictions have similar arrangements, sometimes with combined responsibilities. In some cases, there is an independent regulator; in others, responsibility rests with a government department.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Let's take online advertising as an example. I understand that a great deal of the discussion focuses on broadcasters, traditional television and radio, but I think the elephant in the room, the area that's most difficult to control and regulate, is the digital platforms, which seem to do more or less as they please.

I don't want to ask whether the CRTC has regulatory authority in that area, because you have authority over the broadcasting system as a whole. However, does the CRTC not become indispensable in this context, given the need to regulate digital platforms? Is that something that must necessarily be dealt with by the CRTC and the federal government, or is it something the provinces themselves could do independently if they wished to regulate these matters more or less stringently?

4:10 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

I'll try to answer the question as clearly as possible.

Under the Constitution, sports betting falls within provincial jurisdiction. Provinces may establish advertising restrictions through regulations, policies or provincial legislation. Some have chosen to do so; others have not. That's one of the key differences, and it varies across the country.

As for the CRTC and digital platforms, amendments resulting from the passage of Bill C‑11 have given us the authority, under the Broadcasting Act, to regulate traditional broadcasters as well as online undertakings that carry on broadcasting activities within the meaning of the act, something we've regulated for many years.

However, if we're talking about digital advertisements that appear, for example, in the course of a Google search, that digital platform environment falls outside our mandate. Our jurisdiction is limited to broadcasting.