Evidence of meeting #51 for Canadian Heritage in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site.) The winning word was framework.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Carter  Acting Vice-President, Consumer, Analytics and Strategy, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Apse  Director General, Tobacco Control Directorate, Department of Health
Clare  Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health
Hutton  Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission
Legault  Legislative Clerk
Awad  Director General, Digital and Creative Marketplace Frameworks, Department of Canadian Heritage

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

In that case, will adding another layer of regulation through this bill actually make a difference, given that the provinces are already regulating and overseeing these activities, while we remain unable to intervene where the problem is really spreading?

You mentioned digital platforms that are not broadcasting undertakings as defined by the act. Those platforms will remain beyond our reach in any event. How, then, would this bill add any real enforcement power or regulatory teeth?

4:15 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

As our colleagues have indicated, the role of the CRTC is to ensure that the act is applied to broadcasters. We have the expertise to do that. It's our role within the system, and it's the contribution we will bring to the issue of sports betting advertising. As we stated at the outset, ours is a limited role, and that's the scope of our involvement at present.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Ms. Apse or Mr. Clare, can you tell me, then, how we are going to be able to cover the blind spots that the CRTC, through its power over the broadcasting system, cannot cover? It will inevitably miss them because companies like Google, to name one out of many, are not subject to the Broadcasting Act. How are we going to intervene if we don't have a long enough arm?

4:15 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

It depends on the statutory regime you enact.

Both the Cannabis Act and the Tobacco and Vaping Products Act apply broadly, not just to broadcasters. They apply to all forms of promotion, whether they are digital, print or billboards on the side of highways. All those forms of promotion are regulated under those statutes. Health Canada is the regulator in that regard; it's not the CRTC. As my colleague mentioned, it's Health Canada inspectors who go into facilities and take compliance action. In the case of the Cannabis Act, we have administrative monetary penalties that we can use, like applying fines for non-compliance.

It really depends on the nature of your scheme. In our case, when it comes to cannabis, it applies to online platforms like Twitter, Facebook or Google.

Is regulatory enforcement in the online space a challenge? Absolutely.

This speaks to a second part of your question: What can the federal government bring that provinces can't on their own? In the case of cannabis, it is a co-operative approach. The federal Cannabis Act sets a national standard across the country, but provinces acting in their own jurisdictions can set stricter requirements. In many jurisdictions, provinces have done that in the promotion space.

Collectively, you have a whole suite of tools that can be brought to bear when you have problematic promotion appearing on a digital platform that is quite obviously specifically targeting young people and seeking to induce them to engage in harmful behaviour.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Thank you.

I don't think I have any time left, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

No, you don't.

I will now give the floor to Mr. Hardy for five minutes.

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Thank you.

I'd like to thank everyone for being with us today.

I'm a kinesiologist by training. I've been here for 18 months, and I seem to appreciate my training more and more every day. It is useful in many areas of expertise, here around the table, even with lawyers.

Sport, at its core, is a community. It's about meeting people. You see your friends, you have coaches, you have opponents, you are in public. It's the opposite of isolation. To draw a parallel, I would say that it's about physical health and mental health, while what we're seeing more and more with online gambling platforms is isolation. This is behaviour that is harmful to mental health. It's 100% the opposite of what sport is supposed to do or its very well-documented benefits.

Isn't it a bit worrisome for Health Canada to see this kind of behaviour occur and intrude into sport when it's supposed to be a healthy environment? Isn't it a bit worrisome to see harmful things for our young people being promoted and pushed when everyone is watching their favourite sports with their families, in prime time, on a weekday evening?

4:15 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

The best way I can answer the question, Madam Chair, is to acknowledge that there is a real intersection between a lot of harmful behaviours and some of the issues the member raised, particularly mental health. On the cannabis file exactly, I know there's a real interaction between mental health and cannabis use. It's a real concern that has led the government to enacting the public health framework that it put in place. Part of addressing those harms is using the advertising and promotion restrictions that the Cannabis Act put in place,

As my colleague mentioned, that's just part of a comprehensive strategy to address what you identified: concerns around mental health, particularly among youth. Any restrictions on sports betting and the promotion of sports betting that Parliament sees fit to put in place would need to be part of a comprehensive strategy to address some of the things you mentioned, including mental health.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

I think you raise a good point.

Professional athletes, who are idols of our young people, are not allowed to advertise drugs or tobacco. However, they are literally being allowed to advertise something that has been shown to have a negative impact on the health of young people.

On the one hand, Health Canada wanted to limit an approach that will at some point cost the health care system a lot of money. On the other hand, we know that online gambling has been shown to have a very negative impact on mental health, but we're going to let our stars and our young people's idols promote it.

Don't you think there may be a double standard? As you said, you've legislated on tobacco and cannabis.

4:20 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

My colleague is an expert in tobacco. I'm an expert in cannabis. Neither of us are experts in sports betting and the impact of sports betting on mental health. However, what we can say is that, without a doubt, both of our frameworks prohibit promotion through endorsements because that has been shown to be a form of promotion that is particularly appealing to young persons. That is why our two frameworks do prohibit specifically that type of promotion.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

Here are a few statistics. In 2025, very recently, one in 10 high school students reported having wagered online. In 2019 it was one in a hundred. In six years, there has been a dramatic increase. In addition, one in four students said they see online gambling ads every day. The way online betting is promoted has a huge impact on young people and their lifestyle choices, which will affect their mental health and end up costing the health care system a lot of money.

Do you think we should potentially use an approach that is as restrictive as the one we've adopted for tobacco and cannabis, so that the stars who inspire our young people can't suggest to them, at the end of a hockey game, that they go on their platform to make a small bet?

4:20 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

I appreciate the question. I really do.

As an official with Health Canada, my role is to administer and enforce the Cannabis Act and to provide advice to the minister on the administration of the Cannabis Act. It puts me in an awkward position to say whether or not.... As a public servant, it's not my role to provide advice to the committee on whether or not to enact a specific legislative scheme.

4:20 p.m.

Conservative

Gabriel Hardy Conservative Montmorency—Charlevoix, QC

You just said that you are a public servant. Do you think it would serve the public to ensure that our young people don't become addicted to online gambling?

4:20 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

For sure, I'm a public servant, and I take that very seriously. I also know that my role as a public servant is to provide advice to the government and not to Parliament. However, I can answer questions about the law that we are in charge of administering, for sure.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Ntumba, you have the floor for five minutes.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Good afternoon, everyone.

I think the question that everyone is asking here is fundamental. Why, here and now, does the government or the CRTC not have the power to simply ban advertising for sports betting?

Mr. Hutton, what do you think?

4:20 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

Naturally, our role is limited. We cannot prohibit advertising that can be seen on the side of a bus or on the side of a highway. We deal with broadcasters. Therefore, when certain Internet actors broadcast ads, we can set standards for that purpose, often working together with people from Health Canada, perhaps not those here, but those with expertise in sports betting. We have already started to do our homework on the issue.

That is our role. It's to work with experts. If the legislation is enacted, we will prepare a report and review the rules we have now.

Our current regime is one of co-regulation. We work with an agency that works not only on sports betting ads, but also on all forms of advertising, including those regulated by our colleagues here, those directed at children and those concerning alcohol. That entity has established a code with the gaming industry that covers a number of the topics we're discussing here. The code came into force on January 1 of this year.

The members of the agency include not only broadcasters, but also advertisers and other platforms. The mechanism that the agency has put in place essentially ensures that advertising complies with standards before it is even aired. It's called a pre-broadcast check, and it's very effective for all the other codes we've put in place. It's very well adhered to and there are very few complaints.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Canadians often believe that because an ad is aired on a CRTC-authorized radio station, the CRTC has personally verified and approved its content.

I would like you to explain that.

4:25 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

I'll basically repeat the same thing. We regulate the companies and put in place codes, along with others, that contain standards indicating what should be prohibited in an ad or that address issues such as influence. Influence on children can include standards on the type of individuals, toys or television stars. These are all things that are examined to make sure that ads are up to the standards before they air.

We do this by working with the companies, which also work with broadcasters' associations. We ensure compliance with the standards, when necessary, by including affiliation and compliance with the codes in the licence conditions of the radio stations. We don't do the pre-approval ourselves. We don't approve every ad. The Broadcasting Act says that we can regulate certain things, such as advertising air time. However, we're not in the business of regulating every single ad.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

For the benefit of this committee and all those following us on social media and online, can you clarify how advertising standards are imposed?

4:25 p.m.

Secretary General and Executive Vice-President, Corporate Services and Operations, Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission

Scott Hutton

We impose standards on broadcasters, when necessary, through licence conditions.

We issue licences to broadcasters and, after a certain number of years, we review the conditions that apply. We make sure they're adhered to. We respond strongly to complaints. For advertising, we use bodies like the one that handles standards, processes complaints and resolves them with broadcasters as part of a co-regulatory system.

The Chair Liberal Lisa Hepfner

Thank you.

Mr. Champoux, you now have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'll go back to Health Canada. I was interested in part of Mr. Clare's answer to me earlier when he said that if the provinces had stricter regulations, those regulations would take precedence.

Did I understand your answer earlier, Mr. Clare?

4:25 p.m.

Director General, Cannabis Strategic Policy Directorate, Department of Health

John Clare

No, Madam Chair. To clarify, the way the Cannabis Act works is that it's a federal law that applies across the country. It sets rules for promotion and advertising based on the federal criminal law power. That's the basis of the Cannabis Act, but the way that works is that it sets a standard and, within that, provinces can set more stringent rules.

The best example in the cannabis space is the minimum age for sale. The federal minimum age is 18, but many provinces, including Quebec, have set a higher minimum age.

It's not a question of precedence. It's about the two frameworks working together and, when the Cannabis Act was designed, it was designed specifically with that in mind.

Martin Champoux Bloc Drummond, QC

I would like to draw a parallel, because you are here to talk about the example of tobacco and cannabis, and the long struggle to regulate the tobacco industry. I had a chance, as perhaps some others here did, to listen to Alain Gravel's Radio-Canada podcast on smoking and the fight to compensate smoking victims.

Do you feel that online gambling has the potential to become as harmful a public health problem as tobacco was if it is allowed to go unregulated?

Simply put, will the tobacco experience serve as a basis and a lesson that we will now apply permanently, because we are in a better position to consider and see the dangers of phenomena such as online gambling? Screen addiction and algorithmic feed addiction on social media platforms are also coming to light.

In short, this may be a somewhat broad topic, but to come back to the tobacco example, do you feel that it was the punch in the face we needed to realize that we need to regulate much more quickly for prevention, despite the lobbies and pressures that may come from industries?