Vote #188 on February 7th, 2017

Vote topic

That, given the average middle class Canadian is already overburdened with taxes, the House call on the government to abandon any plans it may have to in any way tax health and dental care plans.

See context in the Debates.

Result

Yes 138
Bloc Conservative NDP Green
No 175
Liberal

Conservative

Yes Ziad Aboultaif
Yes Dan Albas
Yes Harold Albrecht
Yes Dean Allison
Yes Rona Ambrose
Yes David Anderson
Yes Mel Arnold
Yes John Barlow
Yes Candice Bergen
Didn't vote Maxime Bernier
Yes Luc Berthold
Yes James Bezan
Didn't vote Steven Blaney
Yes Kelly Block
Yes Sylvie Boucher
Yes John Brassard
Yes Gord Brown
Yes Blaine Calkins
Yes Colin Carrie
Yes Michael Chong
Yes Alupa Clarke
Yes Tony Clement
Yes Michael Cooper
Yes Gérard Deltell
Yes Kerry Diotte
Yes Todd Doherty
Yes Earl Dreeshen
Yes Jim Eglinski
Yes Ted Falk
Didn't vote Ed Fast
Yes Diane Finley
Yes Cheryl Gallant
Yes Bernard Généreux
Yes Garnett Genuis
Yes Marilyn Gladu
Didn't vote Joël Godin
Yes Jacques Gourde
Yes Randy Hoback
Yes Matt Jeneroux
Yes Pat Kelly
Yes Peter Kent
Yes Robert Gordon Kitchen
Yes Tom Kmiec
Yes Mike Lake
Yes Guy Lauzon
Yes Denis Lebel
Didn't vote Kellie Leitch
Yes Ron Liepert
Yes Ben Lobb
Yes Tom Lukiwski
Yes Dave MacKenzie
Yes Larry Maguire
Yes Kelly McCauley
Yes Phil McColeman
Yes Cathy McLeod
Yes Larry Miller
Yes Glen Motz
Yes John Nater
Yes Rob Nicholson
Yes Alex Nuttall
Didn't vote Deepak Obhrai
Yes Erin O'Toole
Yes Pierre Paul-Hus
Yes Pierre Poilievre
Yes Lisa Raitt
Yes Alain Rayes
Yes Scott Reid
Yes Michelle Rempel
Yes Blake Richards
Yes Gerry Ritz
Yes Bob Saroya
Didn't vote Andrew Scheer
Yes Jamie Schmale
Yes Martin Shields
Yes Bev Shipley
Yes Robert Sopuck
Didn't vote Kevin Sorenson
Yes Bruce Stanton
Yes Mark Strahl
Yes Shannon Stubbs
Yes David Sweet
Yes Rachael Thomas
Yes David Tilson
Yes Bradley Trost
Yes Dave Van Kesteren
Yes Peter Van Loan
Yes Karen Vecchio
Yes Arnold Viersen
Yes Cathay Wagantall
Didn't vote Mark Warawa
Yes Chris Warkentin
Yes Dianne Lynn Watts
Yes Kevin Waugh
Yes Len Webber
Yes Alice Wong
Yes David Yurdiga
Yes Bob Zimmer

NDP

Didn't vote Charlie Angus
Yes Niki Ashton
Yes Robert Aubin
Didn't vote Sheri Benson
Yes Daniel Blaikie
Yes Rachel Blaney
Yes Alexandre Boulerice
Yes Marjolaine Boutin-Sweet
Yes Ruth Ellen Brosseau
Yes Richard Cannings
Yes Guy Caron
Yes François Choquette
Yes David Christopherson
Yes Nathan Cullen
Yes Don Davies
Yes Fin Donnelly
Yes Matthew Dubé
Yes Linda Duncan
Yes Pierre-Luc Dusseault
Yes Scott Duvall
Yes Randall Garrison
Yes Cheryl Hardcastle
Yes Carol Hughes
Yes Gord Johns
Didn't vote Georgina Jolibois
Yes Peter Julian
Yes Jenny Kwan
Yes Hélène Laverdière
Yes Alistair MacGregor
Yes Sheila Malcolmson
Yes Brian Masse
Yes Irene Mathyssen
Yes Christine Moore
Yes Thomas Mulcair
Yes Pierre Nantel
Yes Anne Minh-Thu Quach
Yes Tracey Ramsey
Yes Murray Rankin
Didn't vote Romeo Saganash
Yes Brigitte Sansoucy
Yes Wayne Stetski
Yes Kennedy Stewart
Yes Karine Trudel
Yes Erin Weir

Bloc

Yes Xavier Barsalou-Duval
Didn't vote Mario Beaulieu
Yes Michel Boudrias
Yes Rhéal Fortin
Yes Marilène Gill
Yes Simon Marcil
Yes Monique Pauzé
Yes Louis Plamondon
Yes Gabriel Ste-Marie
Yes Luc Thériault

Liberal

No John Aldag
No Omar Alghabra
No Leona Alleslev
No William Amos
No Gary Anandasangaree
No René Arseneault
No Chandra Arya
No Ramez Ayoub
No Vance Badawey
No Larry Bagnell
No Navdeep Bains
No Frank Baylis
No Terry Beech
No Carolyn Bennett
Didn't vote Marie-Claude Bibeau
No Chris Bittle
No Bill Blair
No Randy Boissonnault
No Mike Bossio
No Bob Bratina
No Pierre Breton
No Scott Brison
No Celina Caesar-Chavannes
No Jim Carr
No Bill Casey
No Sean Casey
No Bardish Chagger
No François-Philippe Champagne
No Arnold Chan
No Shaun Chen
No Serge Cormier
No Rodger Cuzner
No Julie Dabrusin
No Pam Damoff
No Matt DeCourcey
No Sukh Dhaliwal
No Anju Dhillon
No Nicola Di Iorio
Didn't vote Stéphane Dion
No Francis Drouin
No Emmanuel Dubourg
No Jean-Yves Duclos
No Terry Duguid
No Kirsty Duncan
No Julie Dzerowicz
No Wayne Easter
No Ali Ehsassi
No Fayçal El-Khoury
No Neil Ellis
No Nathaniel Erskine-Smith
No Mark Eyking
No Doug Eyolfson
No Greg Fergus
No Andy Fillmore
No Pat Finnigan
No Darren Fisher
No Peter Fonseca
No Judy Foote
No Peter Fragiskatos
No Sean Fraser
No Colin Fraser
Didn't vote Chrystia Freeland
No Hedy Fry
No Stephen Fuhr
No Marc Garneau
No Mark Gerretsen
No Pam Goldsmith-Jones
No Ralph Goodale
No Karina Gould
No David Graham
No Raj Grewal
No Patty Hajdu
No Ken Hardie
No TJ Harvey
No Kent Hehr
No Mark Holland
No Anthony Housefather
No Ahmed Hussen
No Gudie Hutchings
No Angelo Iacono
No Mélanie Joly
No Yvonne Jones
No Bernadette Jordan
No Majid Jowhari
No Darshan Singh Kang
No Iqra Khalid
No Kamal Khera
No David Lametti
No Kevin Lamoureux
No Linda Lapointe
No Stéphane Lauzon
No Dominic LeBlanc
No Diane Lebouthillier
No Paul Lefebvre
No Denis Lemieux
No Andrew Leslie
No Michael Levitt
No Joël Lightbound
No Alaina Lockhart
No Wayne Long
No Lloyd Longfield
No Karen Ludwig
No Lawrence MacAulay
No Steven MacKinnon
No James Maloney
No Rémi Massé
No Bryan May
No Karen McCrimmon
No Ken McDonald
No David McGuinty
No John McKay
No Catherine McKenna
No Ron McKinnon
No Michael McLeod
No Alexandra Mendes
No Marco Mendicino
No MaryAnn Mihychuk
No Marc Miller
No Maryam Monsef
No Bill Morneau
No Bobby Morrissey
No Joyce Murray
No Eva Nassif
No Bob Nault
No Jennifer O'Connell
No Rob Oliphant
No John Oliver
No Seamus O'Regan
Didn't vote Robert-Falcon Ouellette
No Denis Paradis
Didn't vote Joe Peschisolido
No Kyle Peterson
No Ginette Petitpas Taylor
No Jane Philpott
No Michel Picard
No Jean-Claude Poissant
No Carla Qualtrough
No Yasmin Ratansi
Didn't vote Geoff Regan
No Jean Rioux
No Yves Robillard
No Pablo Rodriguez
No Sherry Romanado
Didn't vote Anthony Rota
No Kim Rudd
No Dan Ruimy
No Don Rusnak
No Ruby Sahota
No Raj Saini
No Harjit S. Sajjan
No Darrell Samson
No Ramesh Sangha
No Randeep Sarai
No Francis Scarpaleggia
No Peter Schiefke
No Deb Schulte
No Marc Serré
No Judy Sgro
No Brenda Shanahan
No Terry Sheehan
No Jati Sidhu
No Sonia Sidhu
No Gagan Sikand
No Scott Simms
No Amarjeet Sohi
No Francesco Sorbara
No Sven Spengemann
No Marwan Tabbara
No Geng Tan
No Filomena Tassi
No Justin Trudeau
No Dan Vandal
No Anita Vandenbeld
No Adam Vaughan
No Arif Virani
No Nick Whalen
No Jonathan Wilkinson
No Jody Wilson-Raybould
No Borys Wrzesnewskyj
No Kate Young
No Salma Zahid

Independent

No Hunter Tootoo

Green

Yes Elizabeth May